Wrap a flexible tape around your head at the sweatband line — mid-forehead, just above the ears — and match that circumference to the brand’s own size chart, rounding up between sizes.
Two people with identical head measurements can wear different hat sizes, because a Stetson runs on its own conversion table and a New Era 59FIFTY runs on another. The measurement takes about 30 seconds; what decides fit is knowing exactly where the tape sits and whose chart you read afterward. Get those two things right and you skip the mail-order guessing game. Browse trendy women’s hat styles that fit right once you know your number.
Where Does the Tape Measure Actually Go?
Place the tape at the middle of your forehead and run it around the head where the sweatband will rest — Stetson specifies 1/8 inch above the ear, New Era roughly 1/2 inch above the eyebrows and ears. Same zone, described from two angles.
Keep the tape level, with no twist and no slope. Snug is the target; tight is not. Pulling hard shrinks the reading and yields a hat that squeezes your temples within an hour. Use a flexible cloth tape; with only a rigid ruler, wrap a non-stretchy string around your head, mark the spot, then measure the string flat against the ruler. New Era explicitly allows this substitute.
How Do I Take a Measurement I Can Trust?
Measure at least twice, control your hair the way you’ll wear it under the hat, and record the larger of your consistent readings. Single-reading measurements are the most common reason a hat arrives a size off.
- Hair first. Flatten or position hair as it will normally sit under the hat. Volume, braids, and protective styles all add circumference.
- Repeat the pass. Two or three wraps give you a range; readings that disagree by more than a fraction of an inch mean something is sloping or twisting.
- Write it down. Note both inches and centimeters — most charts list both.
- Then buy. Take that number to the exact model’s chart, not a generic one. Stetson directs anyone between listed sizes to order one size up, and New Era’s chart follows the same round-up rule.
What Do the Stetson Size Numbers Mean?
Stetson’s current size guide pairs each hat label with a traditional hat size, a head circumference in inches, and a metric equivalent. Find your circumference in the middle column, then read left for the label.
| Stetson Label | Hat Size | Head Circumference |
|---|---|---|
| X-Small | 6 5/8 | 21 in / 53 cm |
| Small | 6 7/8 | 21 7/8 in / 55 cm |
| Medium | 7 1/8 | 22 5/8 in / 57 cm |
| Large | 7 3/8 | 23 3/8 in / 59 cm |
| X-Large | 7 5/8 | 24 in / 61 cm |
| 2XL | 7 7/8 | 25 in / 63 cm |
| 3XL | 8 | 25 1/2 in / 64 cm |
Most Stetson steps are about 5/8 inch apart, so a measurement between two rows is exactly the case Stetson’s one-size-up guidance covers. The full table on Stetson’s size guide includes every half-step from 20 1/4 inches up, and Stetson’s blog has its own measuring walkthrough.
Why Doesn’t My Usual Size Work Across Brands?
Fitted, stretch-fit, and adjustable hats use different labels and ranges, so a “large” in one construction isn’t a “large” in another. New Era’s model charts make the gap visible: the 59FIFTY fitted runs 6 7/8 through 8 (21 5/8 to 25 inches); the 39THIRTY stretch-fit uses S/M, M/L, and L/XL bands spanning roughly 22 3/8 to 24 5/8 inches, with some labels overlapping; the 9FIFTY snapback spans about 21 5/8 to 25 3/4 inches. Check the chart for your exact model on New Era’s sizing chart before ordering.
The practical rule: treat an adjustable snapback’s range as a window, not a precise size. It will cover your measurement, but the closure position changes how the crown sits.
What Goes Wrong Most Often?
Most errors trace to four habits — measuring around the crown instead of the sweatband line, pulling the tape tight, letting it twist, or rounding down between sizes. Two more: buying by numerical size without checking the retailer’s current model chart risks a stale size, and buying by label alone assumes “medium” carries the same circumference everywhere, which it plainly does not across these brands.
A properly fitting hat sits securely with no pressure, headache, numbness, or marks on the forehead. If you feel any of those, remeasure rather than waiting for break-in — Stetson and New Era publish sizing guidance, not safety limits, so your own comfort is the final test.
Common Questions
Can I measure my head with a piece of string?
Yes. Wrap a non-stretchy string around your head at the sweatband line, mark where the ends meet, then lay the string flat and measure it with a ruler. New Era explicitly allows a string substitute if you measure the string afterward. Avoid elastic string, which stretches and reads short.
Should I size up or down if I’m between sizes?
Size up. Both Stetson and New Era direct customers between listed sizes to take the next larger one. A slightly loose hat can be adjusted with the sweatband or padding, while a tight one has no give and presses against your forehead.
Does my hairstyle change my hat size?
It can. Measure with hair arranged as it will normally sit under the hat, since volume and protective styles add circumference. If you’ll wear the hat both with hair down and pulled back, measure both ways and use the larger number.
Sources
- Stetson. “Size Guide” Source for the Stetson label, hat size, and circumference conversions.
- New Era. “Sizing Chart” Source for 59FIFTY, 39THIRTY, and 9FIFTY model-specific size ranges.
- Stetson. “How to Determine Your Hat Size” Source for Stetson’s measuring position and one-size-up guidance.