Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
The trick is buying the kit that actually matches your starter’s drive teeth, rotation and spline count, because a near-miss kit wastes a weekend. Below are seven rebuild kits sorted by what they fit, from Harley and Buell solenoids to GM, Ford and Cummins starters, so you can match one to your vehicle before you turn a wrench.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
You do not need a lift or a dealer visit for most of these — a bench, basic hand tools and the right kit cover the job. Match the OEM number first, then pick your rebuild kit from the list below. The right starter rebuild kit turns a no-crank morning into a twenty-minute bench job you can finish yourself.
Top Picks


How To Choose The Best Starter Rebuild Kit
Buying a rebuild kit is a matching job, not a browsing job. The kit has to line up with the starter already bolted to your engine, and three numbers decide that before anything else matters.
Start With The OEM Number, Not The Vehicle Name
Every solenoid and starter carries an original equipment number stamped on it or listed in the parts catalog. The Harley kits here both replace HD# 31604-91, which is the number to check against your own unit before ordering. A kit that lists your model year but not your OEM number is a gamble — pull your old part and read it first.
Check Drive Teeth, Rotation And Spline Count
The drive is the toothed gear that kicks out and spins the flywheel. The Victory Lap GMS-01 serves starters with a 9-T, CW, 3-SPL, 80.8mm long drive — that is 9 teeth, clockwise rotation and 3 splines. The Victory Lap FDS-03 is built for a 10-T, CW, 12-SPL drive on Ford PMGR starters. Count the teeth and splines on your old drive and compare, because a gear that is one tooth off will not mesh.
Decide Between A Contact Set And A Full Kit
Some kits are just the two solenoid contacts and a plunger, which is all a clicking Cummins starter usually needs. Others bundle the drive, bushings, brush set, washers, snap ring and retainer. If your starter cranks slowly or not at all but the motor itself is sound, a contact set is enough. If the drive is chewed up or the brushes are worn down, you want the fuller kit.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Fits | Weight | Kit Contents | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| V-Factor Starter Solenoid Repair Kit★ Best Overall | Harley Big Twin and Sportster solenoid rebuilds | Big Twin 1991–2006, Sportster 1981 and later | — | Solenoid repair kit, copper construction | Amazon |
| Victory Lap GMS-01Most Complete Kit | GM/Delco DD starters on cars, trucks and equipment | GM/Delco 5MT, 8MT, 10MT, SD200, SD300, 1957–1998 | 15.3 ounces | Drive, bushings, two brush sets, washers, snap ring, retainer | Amazon |
| DB Electrical Kit for Honda ATV | Honda TRX four-wheeler starter repair | TRX350FE/FM/TE/TM 2000–2006 and other TRX models | 3.2 ounces | Parts kit with brush holder | Amazon |
| Victory Lap FDS-03 | Ford PMGR starter rebuilds | Ford PMGR starters, 1989–2015 | 13.6 ounces | Drive, bushings, brush holder assembly, snap ring, retainer | Amazon |
| Billet Proof Designs Complete Solenoid Kit | Harley solenoid rebuild without swapping the starter | 1991–2006 Touring, Softail and Dyna (except 2006 Dyna), 1981+ Sportster XL | 0.23 kg | Complete solenoid rebuild kit, metal components | Amazon |
| All Balls 79-1101 | Buell and Harley solenoid rebuilds | Buell Blast through Ulysses, Harley FXST and XL 1200 ranges | — | Solenoid repair kit built to OEM specs | Amazon |
| LarryB’s Heavy Duty Rebuild Kit | Clicking or sticking Cummins starters | 1989–2006 Cummins-powered Dodge Ram trucks | — | Oversized contacts and plunger | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. V-Factor Starter Solenoid Repair Kit
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 250+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
Copper contacts, one OEM number, and a solenoid that hits every time you thumb the button.
If your Harley turns over with a click instead of a crank, this is the kit to reach for first. It replaces HD# 31604-91 and covers Big Twin models from 1991 to 2006 plus Sportster from 1981 and later. That span covers a huge share of the bikes still on the road, which is why it takes the top spot.
The build is copper, and build quality is what wins people over here — the contact surfaces are the part that burns out on a tired solenoid, and a copper set stands up to the repeated arcing that kills the originals. Owners describe it as well-made and functional, and the phrase that keeps coming back is that it hits every time. Installation is described as smooth, with the fit landing right where it should on the stock assembly.
The honest catch sits in the box contents, not the part quality. Some riders open it up and find everything they need, while others end up with a piece that does not match what came out of their bike. Confirm your own solenoid’s OEM stamp before you order rather than trusting the model year alone. Order the right variant and this is a solid, well-priced fix.
What earns its keep
- Fits a very wide Harley span — Big Twin 1991–2006 and Sportster 1981 and later
- Copper construction aimed at the contact surfaces that actually wear
- Replaces the specific HD# 31604-91 unit, so matching is straightforward
- Installs on the stock solenoid without swapping the full starter
Where to slow down
- Kit completeness is the one mixed signal — verify your OEM number before buying
- No listed weight or dimensions, so confirm contents against your old parts
Reach for this if: you ride a Big Twin or Sportster with a clicking solenoid and want a copper contact set that matches the factory number.
Look elsewhere if: your solenoid carries a different OEM stamp — check the part first, because contents vary by variant.
2. Victory Lap GMS-01 Starter Repair Kit
A whole bench-top rebuild in one bag, for the GM starters that ran from 1957 to 1998.
This kit is aimed at the person who wants to rebuild the starter rather than swap one part. It serves GM/Delco 5MT, 8MT, 10MT, SD200 and SD300 series direct-drive starters used in cars, trucks, agricultural and industrial equipment. The fitment window runs 1957 to 1998, which is a very long production tail to cover.
What you get inside is the full spread: the GM long drive, DE and CE bushings, a big brush set, a small brush set, fiber, leather and thrust washers, a snap ring and a snap ring retainer. That is the drive, the bearings and the brushes together, so one order handles the wear points that usually fail as a group. It weighs 15.3 ounces, roughly four and a half times the heft of the DB Electrical Honda kit at 3.2 ounces, which makes sense for a kit carrying a drive gear and bushings.
Instructions come in Spanish, English and French, and the maker pitches it as a good first auto-repair project. Quality and reliability are the two notes that dominate feedback, with the car starting easily afterward being the outcome buyers describe. The part to pay attention to is the drive spec — it is built for a 9-T, CW, 3-SPL, 80.8mm long drive, so count your teeth and splines before ordering.
The value read: you are buying a drive, bushings and two brush sets in one bag instead of hunting each piece separately.
Confirm before you click: the 9-tooth, clockwise, 3-spline drive spec is narrow — a mismatch here is the usual reason a rebuild stalls.
Best for: a first-time rebuilder working on an older GM/Delco direct-drive starter who wants every wear part in one order.
Think twice if: your starter uses a different tooth or spline count than the 9-T, 3-SPL drive this kit carries.
3. DB Electrical Starter Repair Kit
The four-wheeler kit that had an ATV running again within half an hour of the box opening.
Honda TRX owners get a purpose-built kit here, not a universal one. It covers TRX350FE, TRX350FM, TRX350TE and TRX350TM from 2000 to 2006, along with a spread of TRX400, TRX450 and TRX500 models through 2011. It also cross-references a stack of OEM numbers, including Arrowhead SMU9156 and J&N 414-54037, so you can match it against whatever is stamped on your old part.
The kit ships as a parts kit with a brush holder included, and it is a new aftermarket unit built to OEM specifications rather than a reman. It is light — 3.2 ounces — and measures 1.7 x 3.5 x 3.6 inches, so it drops through a letterbox and lives in a small parts drawer until you need it. A one-year warranty backs it if something is wrong from the start.
Functionality and quality are the two things owners talk about most, and the story that keeps surfacing is speed: buyers report “Owners mention it works well, with one ATV running within 30 minutes of installation.” Fit is the mixed note, with some Foreman 450 owners hitting compatibility trouble and a needle bearing coming in the wrong size for a handful. Check your exact model code against the fitment list before ordering.
Why TRX owners pick it
- Purpose-built for a long list of Honda TRX models, 2000 through 2011
- Includes the brush holder, one of the parts that wears first
- Cross-references multiple OEM numbers for easier matching
- Backed by a one-year replacement warranty
The fine print
- Foreman 450 owners have hit fitment snags — confirm your exact model code
- The needle bearing has arrived in the wrong size for some buyers
Pick this one if: you run a TRX350 or a listed TRX500 and want a complete refresh with the brush holder included.
Skip the guesswork: match your model code and OEM number to the list first — that is where the fit complaints start.
4. Victory Lap FDS-03 Starter Repair Kit
Ford PMGR owners get the highest-rated kit on this list, with the drive gear already in the bag.
This one is cut for Ford PMGR starters — the permanent-magnet gear-reduction units used from 1989 to 2015 in cars, trucks, agricultural and industrial work. The drive spec is 10-T, CW, 12-SPL, so it is ten teeth, clockwise rotation and twelve splines. That is a different gear from the 9-tooth GM drive in the GMS-01 above, which is exactly why you check before buying.
Inside the bag you get the drive, several DE and CE bushings, a brush holder assembly, a snap ring and a snap ring retainer. Those bushings matter — they are what keeps the armature spinning true instead of wobbling under load. The kit weighs 13.6 ounces, so there is real metal in the box rather than a bag of springs and shims.
Quality is the note that carries this kit, described as OEM-grade parts by the people installing it, with several saying it meets or beats the factory pieces. Vehicles start reliably afterward, installation goes smoothly, and customers note “Reviewers point out a smooth install and a bill well under a new starter.” Instructions come in Spanish, English and French. Just note the fitment date range ends in 2015 and the drive is specifically the 10-tooth PMGR type.
The standout: a 10-tooth drive plus DE and CE bushings means the two wear-prone areas — gear mesh and bearing slop — get handled in one go.
Watch the year cut: coverage stops at 2015, so a newer Ford needs a different kit entirely.
Go here for: a Ford PMGR starter that needs a fresh drive and bushings, not just contacts.
Not your kit if: your starter is a different gear type or the vehicle falls outside the 1989–2015 window.
5. Complete Starter Solenoid Rebuild Kit
Rebuild the solenoid, keep the starter — the cheapest route to a crank you can take.
When the starter motor itself is fine and only the solenoid has quit, there is no reason to replace the whole assembly. This kit is built around that idea: it replaces the worn solenoid components and leaves a serviceable starter in place. It also replaces HD# 31604-91, the same factory number the V-Factor kit targets.
Fitment covers 1991–2006 Harley Touring, Softail and Dyna models, except the 2006 Dyna, and it also fits 1981 and later Sportster XL models. The distinction to be aware of is that the V-Factor kit lists Big Twin from 1991 to 2006 and Sportster 1981 and later, while this one spells out Touring, Softail and Dyna by name and calls out the 2006 Dyna exception. Read both lists and pick the one whose wording matches your bike.
The kit is metal throughout, weighs 0.23 kg, and the maker’s own guidance is worth following: check the battery, connections and starter circuit before you decide the solenoid is the fault. Owners who got that far describe it working well, including success on a 2000 RG CVO, and the value is the part that lands — a fraction of what a new starter costs.
Suits you if: you have already diagnosed a solenoid fault and want the rebuild-only route on a 1991–2006 Touring, Softail or Dyna.
Rule it out if: you ride a 2006 Dyna — that model is explicitly excluded from the fitment list.
6. All Balls 79-1101 Solenoid Repair Kit
The one kit on this list that actually names the Buell models most buyers get stuck on.
Buell owners get real coverage here. The compatibility list runs Buell Blast 2000–2009, Cyclone 1997–2002, Firebolt XB12R 2005–2009, Firebolt XB9R 2003–2006, Lightning S1 and X1, Lightning XB12S and XB9S, Thunderbolt 1995–2001, and Ulysses XB12X DX and FX. On the Harley side it lists FXST Softail 1989–1991 and a long run of XL 1200 variants covering Custom, Sport and anniversary editions.
It is a 100% new aftermarket solenoid rebuild kit built to meet OEM specifications, and the maker states it meets or exceeds OEM specs for fit and performance. The box is 4.4 x 4.5 x 1.9 inches, which is a bit larger than the DB Electrical Honda kit at 1.7 x 3.5 x 3.6 inches. There is a one-year replacement warranty on it as well.
What this kit offers beyond the others is that Buell-specific coverage. If you have a Firebolt or a Ulysses and the starter solenoid has gone quiet, most generic Harley kits will leave you guessing. Here the model names are spelled out. Check your year against the list carefully, though — the XL 1200 entries jump around by submodel and year, and the Softail coverage is a narrow 1989–1991 window.
Where it wins: named Buell fitment through Blast, Cyclone, Firebolt, Lightning, Thunderbolt and Ulysses — coverage the Harley-focused kits skip.
Where to look closely: the Harley side is narrow in places, with FXST Softail limited to 1989–1991.
Your kit if: you own a Buell from the listed ranges and need a solenoid rebuild with the model actually named on the box.
Double-check first: your specific XL 1200 or Softail year — the Harley entries are submodel-specific rather than a blanket fit.
7. LarryB’s Starter Solenoid Rebuild kit
Contacts with roughly 90% more surface area, built for the Cummins starter that keeps clicking.
If your 1989 to 2006 Cummins-powered Dodge Ram clicks a few times before it cranks, or sticks on entirely, this kit goes straight at the cause. The maker states the super-size solenoid contacts carry approximately 90% more contact area than stock and are designed to carry twice the voltage load. The unit is rated at 2 KW and fits Denso gear-reduction starters on those trucks.
That contact area is the whole point. A stock starter uses two contacts that burn as the solenoid arcs, and typically only one gets badly scorched — which is why the maker recommends replacing both contacts and the plunger while the starter is apart. More surface means more metal to burn through before the click returns. Reliability is the thing everyone raves about, and shoppers say “Buyers report it has kept a Cummins starting for six months and cleared the click-and-no-crank.” The install is described as doable with minimal hand tools, and the fit lands right.
The savings are the second reason Cummins owners rate it. A fresh starter is a serious bill, and owners mention “Customers find the starter solenoid kit reliable, reporting it has been working for six months and solving starting issues” — alongside the cost win of not buying a whole new starter. Contact size is the one note that splits opinion, with a few wanting it bigger still. Given how consistently customers note the durability holds up, it is the stronger pick if you want to fix it once.
Why Cummins owners rate it
- Contacts with approximately 90% more surface area than stock
- Designed to carry twice the voltage load for easier starting
- Rated at 2 KW and built for Denso gear-reduction starters
- Installs with minimal hand tools on a bench
What to keep in mind
- Contact size draws mixed feedback — a few want it larger
- Fitment is locked to 1989–2006 Cummins Dodge Ram trucks only
Built for: a Cummins Ram owner chasing a click-and-no-crank who wants oversized contacts and a plunger in one order.
Outside its lane: anything that is not a 1989–2006 Cummins-powered Dodge Ram with a Denso starter.
Know the Specs
Drive Teeth And Splines
The drive is the toothed gear that pops out and spins your flywheel. Tooth count and spline count have to match the starter it goes into — the Victory Lap GMS-01 carries a 9-T, 3-SPL drive, while the FDS-03 carries a 10-T, 12-SPL drive. Count both on your old gear before you order, because a one-tooth mismatch will not mesh and the starter will grind.
Brush Holders And Brushes
Brushes are the carbon blocks that pass current to the spinning armature, and the holder is the cage that keeps them pressed in place. As they wear down, cranking gets slow and then stops. The DB Electrical Honda kit ships with a brush holder, and the Victory Lap GMS-01 includes a big and a small brush set. If your starter turns lazily, brushes are often the reason.
Contacts And Plungers
Inside the solenoid, a plunger bridges two contacts to send power to the motor. Those contacts pit and burn over time, which is the source of the click. LarryB’s oversize contacts carry approximately 90% more contact area than stock, and the maker recommends replacing both contacts and the plunger together while the starter is apart.
OEM Numbers And Fitment
The OEM number is the factory part reference stamped on your original component. Both Harley solenoid kits here replace HD# 31604-91, and the DB Electrical kit cross-references numbers like Arrowhead SMU9156 and J&N 414-54037. Pull your old part and read that number — it beats guessing from the model year, especially where a kit excludes a specific year such as the 2006 Dyna.
Common Questions
How do I know whether a starter rebuild kit fits my vehicle?
What is the difference between a contact kit and a full rebuild kit?
My starter clicks but the engine will not crank — is the solenoid the problem?
Can I rebuild a starter with basic hand tools?
How long does a solenoid rebuild kit tend to last?
Which kit fits a Buell Firebolt or Ulysses?
Is a solenoid rebuild kit cheaper than a new starter?
What does 9-T, CW, 3-SPL actually mean on a starter drive?
Do these kits come with a warranty?
Can I install one of these kits on a 2006 Dyna?
The Bottom Line
For most riders chasing a click instead of a crank, the starter rebuild kit worth starting with is the V-Factor Starter Solenoid Repair Kit — copper contacts, the HD# 31604-91 match, and a Big Twin and Sportster fit window that covers most of the bikes on the road. If you want the fuller bench rebuild with drive and bushings, the Victory Lap GMS-01 puts every wear part in one bag. And for the Cummins Ram that keeps clicking, the LarryB’s Heavy Duty Rebuild Kit is the fix that puts oversize contacts in while the starter is apart.
One last push toward the bench: the top pick carries a 4.5+ star rating, and its copper contacts are built to outlast the factory pieces they replace — that is the kit to order first if you have not pulled your solenoid apart yet.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of November 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Tactical Gear Guy earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.




