Size a well pressure tank by matching its published drawdown at your cut-in and cut-out pressures to your pump’s flow rate times your target runtime.
A tank labeled 44 gallons might hold only 12 gallons of usable water at 40/60 PSI — and that gap is why so many wells short-cycle. Sizing a well water pressure tank correctly means working from drawdown, pump flow, and pressure-switch settings, then confirming the model’s connections and pressure rating before you buy.
What Numbers Do You Need Before Choosing A Tank?
Four inputs drive the whole calculation: pump flow in gallons per minute, your desired pump runtime in minutes, the pressure switch’s cut-in and cut-out settings, and the tank’s rated drawdown at those pressures.
Pump flow comes from the pump curve, not the label on the motor. Read the flow at cut-in pressure and again at cut-out pressure, then average the two figures. That average is the number the sizing math uses.
How Do You Calculate Required Drawdown?
Multiply pump flow by your target runtime. A 10 GPM pump with a 1-minute minimum runtime needs at least 10 gallons of drawdown.
- Short runtime (under 1 minute): frequent cycling, added wear on the pump motor.
- 1 to 2 minutes: the common residential target that keeps the pump from starting on every faucet drip.
- Longer runtime: fewer starts, but demands a bigger tank and more floor space.
Once you have the required drawdown, open the manufacturer’s table for your cut-in/cut-out pair and pick the first model whose drawdown meets or beats that figure. Amtrol’s full-acceptance procedure runs six steps: establish precharge and switch pressures, average the pump capacity, calculate the acceptance factor, confirm it stays under the series maximum, compute total tank volume, then select a model at or above that volume.
| Cut-In / Cut-Out | Tank Precharge | What To Watch |
|---|---|---|
| 20 / 40 PSI | 18 PSI | Lowest drawdown per gallon of tank size |
| 30 / 50 PSI | 28 PSI | Precharge stays 2 PSI under cut-in |
| 40 / 60 PSI | 38 PSI | Most common residential setting |
| 50 / 70 PSI | 48 PSI | Verify pump can reach 70 PSI at the house |
| 60 / 80 PSI | 58 PSI | Check tank and relief valve ratings |
| Any change to switch | Reset to cut-in minus 2 | Recalculate drawdown too |
Why Does Precharge Matter As Much As Tank Size?
Set the air precharge 2 PSI below the pump cut-in pressure, with the water side fully drained. A 40/60 PSI system calls for 38 PSI of air, which Amtrol’s installation manual states directly.
Checking pressure with water still in the tank gives a false reading, and setting precharge at or above cut-in leaves you with almost no usable drawdown — the tank behaves like a small one no matter how large the shell is. Amtrol’s manual notes that any change to the pressure switch requires a matching precharge adjustment and a fresh drawdown calculation.
Beyond the tank itself, confirm the model’s working pressure and connection size. If you’d rather compare assembled setups than build one from scratch, browse these tested well water pump and pressure tank picks before committing to a model.
The sizing procedure and model data come from Amtrol’s Well-X-Trol sizing guide, which lays out the full-acceptance method step by step.
What Goes Wrong Most Often?
Buying by nominal gallon capacity is the single most common error — a big shell with thin drawdown still short-cycles the pump. The second is ignoring the pump curve and guessing at flow.
- Setting precharge with system pressure still present.
- Skipping the relief valve or fitting one rated below the system’s maximum pressure.
- Changing switch settings without recalculating drawdown.
- Forgetting elevation and friction loss between the tank and the fixtures.
- Mounting the tank far from the pressure switch, which skews the readings.
Install the tank as close to the pressure switch as practical, and make sure the floor or bracket carries the tank’s full operating weight with water in it. Overpressure can rupture a tank and cause flooding or injury, so never exceed the working pressure stamped on the nameplate.
Common Questions
Can A Tank Be Too Big For A Well System?
An oversized tank is safe but wasteful. It costs more, takes up more floor space, and holds water longer than needed, which can affect freshness in some systems. Size to the calculated drawdown and stop there rather than rounding up to the largest model available.
Does A Bigger Tank Increase Water Pressure?
No. Pressure comes from the pump and the pressure switch settings, not tank volume. A larger tank extends runtime between pump starts and steadies the flow, but the cut-out setting still determines the highest pressure your fixtures see.
How Often Should Precharge Be Checked?
Check air precharge once a year, and any time the pump starts cycling oddly or a faucet sputters. Drain the water side first, then read the air valve with a standard tire gauge and top up to 2 PSI below cut-in.
Sources
- Amtrol. “Sizing the Well-X-Trol” Six-step full-acceptance sizing procedure and pump-curve averaging method.
- Amtrol. “Well-X-Trol Installation and Operation Manual” Precharge settings, connection sizes, and installation clearances.
- Amtrol. “Well-X-Trol Pressure Tanks” Product family overview and working pressure reference.