9 Best Tow Hitch Spares | 5/8-Inch Pins That End Hitch Slop

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.

Here is the honest answer: the right tow hitch spare is the one that matches your receiver’s pin hole and your shank diameter, and gets changed before the wire clip rusts through. Most towing trouble doesn’t come from a failing hitch, it comes from a missing clip, a stretched cotter pin, or a cover that has gone brittle after two winters. The picks below cover all three jobs — keeping the pin in, keeping the pin locked, and keeping the hardware dry.

This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.

I split the kit into four buckets: the lock-and-cover parts that hide your pin entirely, the bulk pin assortments that replace half the hardware box, the single replacement pins for a specific receiver, and the damage-repair pieces. Every dimension below is quoted as the maker publishes it, so you can tape-measure your receiver before you order. From rubber covers to hitch pins, here is what holds up on a moving trailer.

Top Picks

HitchSafe HS7010 Replacement Color Black
Best OverallHitchSafe HS7010 Replacement Color Black4.5+★700+ ratingsThe smallest part in the box, and the one that keeps your hitch lock working at all. If your hitch lock is the kind that hides the pin inside the receiver, this is the piece that fails first.Check price on Amazon
150PCS Premium 304 Stainless Steel Clevis Pins Cotter Pins R Clips Assortment Kit
Workshop Staple150PCS Premium 304 Stainless Steel Clevis Pins Cotter Pins R Clips Assortment Kit4.5+★650+ ratingsOne box that ends every future trip to the hardware store for a single missing clip. This is the box you buy once and then reach into for years.Check price on Amazon
300 Pcs R-Clip Cotter Pin Assortment Kit, 304 Stainless Steel Hairpin Clips
Quick-Release Stock300 Pcs R-Clip Cotter Pin Assortment Kit4.5+★100+ ratingsFinger-pressure removal, hundreds of times over — no pliers required at the pin hole. Count the clips first: 300 of them, all the same hairpin shape, spread across seven metric sizes from M1×16mm up to M3×65mm.Check price on Amazon

How To Choose The Best Tow Hitch Spares

Buying hitch hardware starts with a tape measure, not a product page. Before you look at any kit, take a tape to the pin hole in your receiver tube and the shank of the ball mount that slides into it. That one number — 5/8-inch on most Class III, IV and V setups — decides half the list for you, and getting it wrong means the pin either won’t pass through or passes through with slop.

Measure the pin hole and the shank, in that order

The pin goes through both the receiver wall and the ball mount shank, so both need to agree. A 5/8-inch diameter pin with 3-1/2 inches of usable length pairs with a 2-inch shank and a 5/8-inch hole. If your receiver uses a smaller hole, a bulk assortment with a spread of metric sizes is the safer buy than a single pin, because you are not gambling on one dimension. Check the hole diameter and required clip size before use on any assortment kit.

Decide if you want steel or stainless

Zinc plating is a coating, and coatings wear off where the pin rubs against the receiver wall or where the clip drags. A 304 stainless steel pin or clip is the same metal all the way through, so a scratch doesn’t start a rust line. For a rig that sits outside, or a mower that lives in a damp shed, stainless is the more forgiving choice. For a truck that gets used weekly and kept indoors, plated steel holds up fine.

Match the clip style to how often you pull the pin

A cotter pin bends into place and needs pliers and a new pin when you remove it. A hairpin R-clip slides in and out with your fingers, which is why it shows up on PTO shafts and tractor three-point linkage. A linch pin combines a pin and a spring clip in one piece. If you swap implements or ball mounts several times a week, spend the extra on the clip style you can remove by hand.

Don’t forget the parts that fail quietly

The most common failure is not a snapping pin — it’s the cover over the lock, or the coupler latch that no longer clamps. Rubber covers go brittle with UV and road salt, and a coupler that won’t grip the ball is a trailer that won’t sit still. Both are cheap fixes compared with replacing the whole lock assembly or the whole coupler, which is why they belong in the spare-parts box alongside the pins.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Model Best For Type Material Piece Count / Size Amazon
HitchSafe HS7010 Replacement Cover★ Best Overall Replacing a worn lock cover Replacement cover Rubber with metal frame 3 x 1 x 2 inches, 1.6 oz Amazon
150PCS Premium 304 Stainless Clevis & Cotter Pin KitWorkshop Staple Workshop restock box Clevis, cotter and R-clip mix 304 stainless steel 150 pieces, 15 sizes Amazon
300 Pcs R-Clip Cotter Pin Assortment KitQuick-Release Stock Hand-removable clip stock Hairpin R-clips 304 stainless steel 300 pieces, 7 metric sizes Amazon
TOPSHINE Trailer Hitch Pin & Clip 4 Pack Two-vehicle households Hitch pin plus R-clip High-strength steel, zinc plated 5/8 inch dia, 3-1/2 inch usable Amazon
Eaz-Lift Camco Trailer Tongue Ball Plate (48388) Sway control rebuild Tongue ball and plate Blend material, brushed finish 16 oz, 1 piece Amazon
CURT 21579 Black Trailer Hitch Pin & Clip Single receiver, daily driver Hitch pin plus clip Solid steel, black zinc 5/8 inch dia, 2-inch receiver Amazon
Reese Towpower 74797 Coupler Repair Kit Class 2 coupler repair Coupler repair kit Steel, zinc finish Fits 2-inch couplers Amazon
202PCS Hitch Pins Clip Pins (Linch and PTO) Farm and tractor hardware PTO, lynch and cotter mix Zinc plated steel 202 pieces Amazon
B&W Hitches TS35010 Stainless Pin Set Tow and Stow owners Hitch pin with keeper clips Stainless steel 3 pieces, 0.63 inch dia Amazon

Detailed Reviews

★ Best Overall

1. HitchSafe HS7010 Replacement Color Black

Our pick — 4.5+★ from 700+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.

Rubber over metal frameLock cover replacement

The smallest part in the box, and the one that keeps your hitch lock working at all.

If your hitch lock is the kind that hides the pin inside the receiver, this is the piece that fails first. The HS7010 is a replacement cover built from rubber wrapped around a metal frame, and it slots onto the flange of an existing HitchSafe so the whole assembly stays sealed against road spray and grit. It weighs 1.6 ounces and measures 3 x 1 x 2 inches, which tells you the tolerances here are fine — this is not a part you want to force.

You get a part that behaves like the factory original, so you don’t have to buy a whole new lock because a rubber boot cracked. The rubber-and-frame build is finished in powder coat with an anti-corrosion treatment (a coating that fights rust). The maker describes the fit as tight and secure, which is what a cover sealing water out of a lock body needs.

The honest catch is that rubber weathers. The cover stands up to normal use, but this is a rubber part living outside under UV and salt, and some buyers report the material turning brittle over its life. That is a fair note rather than a warning: treat it as a wear item, check it each season, and budget to swap it again eventually. The one-year warranty backs the build but not indefinitely.

What makes it the sensible first buy

  • Fit quality is the whole point — described in the maker’s own specs as tight and secure on the flange
  • Rubber over a metal frame, powder coated with anti-corrosion treatment, at 1.6 ounces
  • Replaces just the cover, so you keep the lock body you already paid for
  • Covered by a 1-year manufacturer warranty

Where it asks for a little care

  • Rubber weathers with sun and salt — expect to replace it again rather than never
  • Designed only for HitchSafe flanges, so it will not fit a generic receiver lock
  • Small part, real consequence: a cracked cover left on means water sitting against metal

Plays well with: anyone already running a HitchSafe who wants to restore the seal rather than replace the assembly.

Not the one for you if: you run a different brand of receiver lock — this cover keys to HitchSafe’s flange slots only.

Workshop Staple

2. 150PCS Premium 304 Stainless Steel Clevis Pins Cotter Pins R Clips Assortment Kit

15 sizes304 stainless

One box that ends every future trip to the hardware store for a single missing clip.

This is the box you buy once and then reach into for years. It holds 150 pieces split across 15 sizes, mixing clevis pins with the single-hole flat head, cotter pins, and hairpin R-clips. The clevis pins lock tightly against a cotter pin or an R-clip so a joint doesn’t work loose under vibration. Since it throws three fastener types into one case, you are not hunting for a specific style — you open the lid and match the size.

What people value most is the steel itself. The whole set is 304 stainless steel, which resists rust on its own rather than relying on a zinc coating that rubs away. Owners routinely compare it favourably against zinc-plated and carbon steel alternatives on exactly that point. Variety gets the second-biggest nod — the size spread covers enough ground that one kit handles a trailer pin, a mower deck and a garage door linkage without a second order. The whole set weighs 15.37 ounces and packs into a labelled reusable case with clear dividers.

Here is the thing to know before you commit: 150 pieces is a lot of hardware, but 15 sizes means fewer of any single size than a dedicated bulk pack of one clip. If you burn through one specific size — say, the clip on your ball mount — this kit will run down that compartment faster than you’d like. It rewards the person who needs breadth across jobs, not the person who needs a lifetime supply of one pin.

Where it earns its place: the stainless steel body is why you pick this over a cheaper zinc-plated kit — there is no coating to scratch off. The polished finish stays smooth, so clips slide in and out without a tool.

One practical limit: the reusable case with labelled dividers is genuinely useful, but it’s plastic, and it’s the kind of case that lives in a toolbox rather than a truck bed. Keep it indoors and it will outlast the clips.

The right call for: a home workshop or a car-repair bench that wants one labeled case covering clevis, cotter and R-clip jobs in stainless.

Keep looking if: your only need is a big bag of one exact size — a single-type pack stretches further per dollar.

Quick-Release Stock

3. 300 Pcs R-Clip Cotter Pin Assortment Kit

7 metric sizesHairpin design

Finger-pressure removal, hundreds of times over — no pliers required at the pin hole.

Count the clips first: 300 of them, all the same hairpin shape, spread across seven metric sizes from M1×16mm up to M3×65mm. The straight leg drops through a cross-drilled hole while the curved spring leg stays outside and grips the shaft, so the clip stays put under vibration but comes off with your thumb. That is the whole appeal for anyone who swaps a ball mount or a three-point implement regularly. Compare that to the TOPSHINE pack’s 4 pins and clips and the gap is obvious: this kit is built for repeat swaps, not a single install.

Quality is what owners talk about first, and the material backs it up — 304 stainless steel throughout, polished, with the corrosion resistance that matters when a mower deck or a trailer sits outside. The transparent multi-compartment case has a printed size chart on the lid, which sounds minor until you are hunting a 1.8mm clip in the dark. Compatible groove diameter is listed at 0.16 inches, so do check your hole before ordering a specific size.

The trade-off is that these are small-diameter clips. The M1 and M1.2 sizes are for light retaining work, not for holding a loaded trailer pin under highway load. Buy this for the PTO shafts, linkage pins, mower decks and small-engine work it was clearly aimed at, and buy a proper 5/8-inch pin for the receiver. It is a complement to your hitch hardware, not a replacement for it.

Built for the swap-happy: 300 stainless hairpins in seven sizes means you can lose one, fit a spare, and keep the tractor running without a store run.

Made for: tractor, mower and small-engine owners who pull pins by hand several times a season and want a labeled case that survives the toolbox.

Think twice if: you need a load-rated receiver pin — these hairpins top out at M3×65mm and belong on linkage, not on a highway tow.

Two-Rig Pick

4. TOPSHINE Trailer Hitch Pin & Clip 4 Pack

4 pins, 4 R-clipsVinyl-coated handle

Four matching pin-and-clip sets, so one can live in the toolbox and one in the glove box.

The spec that matters: a 5/8-inch diameter and 3-1/2 inches of usable length, sized for a 2-inch shank with a 5/8-inch pin hole. That covers most Class III and IV receivers and the common trailer accessories that slide into them. You get four pins and four R-cotter clips in the pack, which is the practical difference between this and a single-pin buy — a kid’s truck, a work truck and a spare can all be sorted at once. Compare it to the CURT pin below and the length is the story: 3-1/2 inches of usable length against a shorter single pin.

High-strength steel with a zinc-plated finish handles the wear and the weather, and both the pin and the clip are black vinyl-coated at the handle end. That coating is a small thing that matters in February — a bare steel handle at minus temperatures is not something you want to grip without gloves. The tapered end slides in easily, and the bend in the pin acts as a handle while keeping the pin seated.

The honest caveat is fit: some receivers take the pin cleanly and others need a nudge. Some receivers take the pin cleanly, others need a nudge to line up, which is normal for a 5/8-inch pin in a 5/8-inch hole if the receiver has seen a few seasons. Try it dry before you tow, and if it binds, a light clean of the hole usually sorts it. The 2.44-pound pack weight tells you these are substantial pins, not stamped-out ones.

Why the four-pack makes sense

  • Four pins and four clips in one order — one per vehicle, plus spares
  • 5/8-inch diameter with 3-1/2 inches usable length for 2-inch shank receivers
  • Vinyl-coated handle on the pin and the clip for grip in cold weather
  • Tapered tip and bent handle make insertion and removal a one-hand job

What to expect on fit

  • Fit is the most argued point — a worn receiver can make the pin bind on first insert
  • Zinc plating rather than stainless, so keep it out of standing water where the coat can wear
  • Buying four only pays off if you have a second receiver or want spares on the shelf

Go here for: two or more tow vehicles, or anyone who wants a matched spare set before a long trip rather than after a lost clip.

One caveat worth knowing: that 3-1/2-inch usable length is generous, so check your receiver tube isn’t shorter than the pin needs.

Sway Fix

5. Eaz-Lift Camco Trailer Tongue Ball Plate 48388

Left or right mountPrepunched holes

A one-piece tongue ball and plate that gets a sway-control bar back on the trailer.

This is not a pin at all, and it belongs in a hitch-spares box for a different reason: it’s the part that fails when a sway control system’s mounting point gets bent or stripped. The 48388 is a replacement tongue ball and plate for the Eaz-Lift Sway Control System, and it works on either the left or the right side mount. At 16 ounces it’s a solid chunk of hardware — compare it to the 1.6-ounce HitchSafe cover and you can see these are two entirely different orders of part.

The brushed finish and prepunched holes are the details that sell it. Prepunched means you bolt it on rather than drilling in your driveway, and owners consistently report it lines up with existing holes. It bolts on and it works with any brand of sway bar, which is the kind of cross-compatibility that saves you from buying a matching-brand bar to go with it. Functionality is the second thing people point to after build quality — this is a part people buy to solve a problem, and it solves it.

The catch is what it doesn’t do. It’s a replacement for the Eaz-Lift system specifically, not a universal plate, and it’s vehicle-specific fit by the maker’s own description. If your sway control is a different design, this is not the part. And if the ball itself is fine and only the plate is bent, you may find yourself buying more than you need. But as a straight replacement when the whole assembly is tired, it’s the simple answer.

The part you want when: the tongue ball on an Eaz-Lift sway setup is worn, stripped or bent and the trailer needs the bar back.

Look elsewhere when: you run a different sway-control brand or only need a single fastener — this is a system-specific replacement, not a universal fit.

Daily Driver

6. CURT 21579 Trailer Hitch Pin & Clip

5/8-inch diameter105-degree bend

Solid steel, a 105-degree handle bend, and a black zinc coat that shrugs off weather.

For a truck with one receiver and one ball mount, this is the pin to keep in it. The 5/8-inch diameter matches any ball mount or hitch accessory with a 2-inch shank and a 5/8-inch pin hole, and CURT lists it as fitting most Class 3, 4 and 5 trailer hitches. The compatible groove diameter measures 0.63 inches, which is the 5/8-inch pin measured on the nose — the two are the same figure expressed two ways, so don’t be confused reading the spec sheet.

Daily use is easier because of the 105-degree bend, which turns the pin into a handle you can grip and pull without hunting for a tool. The black zinc plating keeps rust off the surface, and solid steel underneath means the pin doesn’t flex when the load shifts. You get a single pin and clip, not a pack — the flip side of the TOPSHINE four-pack above, where you get spares but not one pin as heavily finished.

Installation is as simple as it gets: slide the accessory into the receiver, line up the pin holes in the side of the tube, push the pin through, and fit the clip. The one limitation worth flagging is that the handle bend gives you grip but not a locking mechanism — if you want theft deterrence, this pin comes out as easily for a stranger as it does for you. That’s not a flaw in the pin, it’s a different purchase entirely.

The case for one good pin: a 5/8-inch solid steel pin with black zinc plating, a 105-degree grip bend, and a clip that keeps it engaged on every mile.

The follow-up question: receivers that have collected rust or grit can make the pin stiff on first insert — clean the hole before you blame the pin.

Fits the bill for: the one-receiver truck owner who wants a well-finished pin that stays put and grips comfortably.

Skip if: you want a pin that also locks — this one is pure hardware with no keyed security.

Coupler Rescue

7. Reese Towpower 74797 Coupler Repair Kit, SILVER

3,500 lbs GVWFits 2-inch couplers

When the latch won’t clamp anymore, this rebuilds the coupler instead of the trailer.

A worn coupler latch is the quiet failure in a towing setup — the trailer sits on the ball but won’t lock down, so every bump works it loose. This kit is Reese’s answer, packing the parts needed to repair a damaged Class 2 trailer coupler. It’s rated for 3,500 lbs GVW, which is the number to check against your trailer’s gross weight before you order: a lightweight utility trailer, a small boat or a single-axle camper fits that band.

The compatibility line is short and important. It’s designed for 2-inch couplers and no others — so measure the ball your trailer sits on before you buy. The steel is premium quality with a bright zinc finish for corrosion resistance, and Reese backs it with a limited 3-year warranty, which is a longer commitment than you’ll find on most hardware in this list.

The honest snag is the latch’s clamping grip. Owners mention that fit and installation win praise and the kit is well-built, but the clamping action divides opinion — some owners find it holds securely without marking the chrome on the ball, while others can’t get it to clamp down at all. A rebuild kit struggles on a worn or out-of-round ball; this kit wants a fresh ball and a properly aligned coupler.

Where the value sits: rebuild a tired Class 2 coupler rather than replace the whole unit, with a 3,500 lbs GVW rating and a 3-year limited warranty.

Check before you buy: the clamping action is the mixed part — a ball that’s out of round or a coupler that’s bent out of alignment may keep it from locking down properly.

Worth reaching for if: you tow a Class 2 trailer on a 2-inch coupler and the latch has lost its grip but the coupler body is sound.

Different job entirely if: the coupler itself is cracked or deformed — then you’re replacing the unit, not repairing it.

Farm Kit

8. 202PCS Hitch Pins Clip Pins

202 piecesZinc plated steel

Square PTO pins, lynch pins and hairpin cotters — the whole tractor hardware drawer in one case.

This is the biggest mixed box here at 202 pieces, and the mix is what sells it. Square PTO pins, lynch pins and hairpin cotter pins all land in one double-sided organizer with removable plastic dividers, so you can shuffle compartments around to fit whatever sizes you use most. Compatible groove diameter is listed at 1.25 inches, which is a hefty size — these are built for farm equipment rather than a car hitch.

What people value most is the breadth of styles. A trailer ball pin that snapped, a dolly pin, a keeper pin, a hand truck pin — this kit is pitched as a replacement for all of them, and the variety is the reason. Quality runs close behind, with the zinc-plated steel delivering rust and corrosion resistance for outdoor long-term use. It’s not 304 stainless, so it’s a coated steel rather than a through-and-through one, and that difference matters over a decade of weather.

The trade-off is that breadth costs you depth. A 202-piece box spread across PTO pins, lynch pins and hairpins means you don’t get a huge count of any one type, and the 1.25-inch groove diameter narrows the fit to heavier equipment. This is a farm and workshop purchase, not a commuter’s hitch spare — a weekend tower with a single 2-inch receiver will find most of these pieces too big.

Why farm shops pick it

  • 202 pieces across square PTO pins, lynch pins and hairpin cotter pins in one organizer
  • Double-sided case with removable dividers you can rearrange to your own layout
  • Zinc-plated steel for rust and corrosion resistance in outdoor use
  • Replaces a long list of tired pins — ball, dolly, keeper, retainer and hand truck

Where it narrows

  • Comparable groove diameter is 1.25 inches, so light-duty receivers are out of scope
  • Zinc plated rather than stainless — good for years, but a coating can wear through
  • Breadth over depth: no single style arrives in bulk quantity

A solid grab for: tractor, mower and farm-equipment owners who need PTO and lynch hardware in one organized case.

Wrong fit if: your trailer runs a standard 2-inch receiver — the 1.25-inch groove sizing is aimed at heavier machinery.

Stainless Set

9. B&W Hitches TS35010 Tow and Stow Stainless Steel Receiver Hitch Pins

3 pinsHigh-tensile stainless

Three stainless pins built for one specific hitch — and the difference shows in the metal.

The headline here is material rather than size: these are made from high-tensile strength stainless steel, which is what gives them the durability and the long-lasting looks the maker promises. Stainless means the rust resistance runs through the pin, not just on its surface, so a scraped pin at a tight receiver doesn’t start a rust line. The compatible groove diameter is 0.63 inches — the same 5/8-inch figure as the CURT and TOPSHINE pins — so the size itself isn’t unusual. What you’re paying for is the metal and the three-pin set.

They’re designed specifically for the B&W Tow and Stow line of receiver hitches, and that specificity is the whole point. If you own that hitch, these are an exact match and they fit as the hitch intended. The polished or brushed finish keeps them looking like new longer than plated alternatives, and the set weight of 3 pounds tells you these are substantial pieces. A three-pin set also means you have a spare when one goes missing, which happens more than anyone admits.

The honest limit is that these pins are cut for one hitch line. If you don’t own a B&W Tow and Stow hitch, the value of a matched three-pin stainless set is lower — the pins are excellent, but you’re paying for a fit you may not need. For the owner of that hitch, though, it’s the cleanest replacement part you can buy, and it removes any question of fit.

The standout spec: high-tensile stainless steel in a 0.63-inch pin, three to a set, with a polished or brushed finish that holds its look.

The fit question: designed for the B&W Tow and Stow line specifically — check your hitch model before you order, because a universal pin will work elsewhere for less.

The right part when: you run a B&W Tow and Stow hitch and want a stainless, matched three-pin set that fits as the maker designed.

Not worth it when: your receiver is a different brand — a matched set buys you fit, and without that hitch you’re paying for a fit you won’t use.

Know the Specs

Pin Diameter and Receiver Class

Pin diameter is the governing number on any hitch pin: a 5/8-inch pin fits a 2-inch receiver with a 5/8-inch pin hole, which covers most Class III, IV and V setups. A 0.63-inch compatible groove diameter is the same 5/8-inch figure described a different way — don’t read it as a second, larger pin. The pin diameter has to match the hole in both the receiver wall and the shank, so measure both before you order. Wrong diameter means slop, rattle, or a pin that simply won’t pass through.

Stainless vs. Zinc Plating

Zinc plating is a coating applied over steel; stainless steel is a metal that resists rust all the way through. A plated pin can develop a rust line where the coating wears at a rub point; a 304 stainless pin or clip stays rust-resistant even after a scratch. For hardware that lives outside, stainless is more forgiving but often carries a premium. For a piece used indoors or on a weekly basis and cleaned regularly, a zinc-plated part is a sensible, cost-effective choice — as long as you accept that the coating is the wear surface.

Clip Styles: Cotter, Hairpin and Lynch

A cotter pin bends into place and stays put under vibration — secure, but it needs pliers to remove and is a single-use part in practice. A hairpin R-clip slides in and out with your fingers; the straight leg passes through the hole and the curved spring leg grips the shaft from outside. A lynch pin is a heavier combination of a pin and a spring keeper. Choose by how often you swap the implement: frequent swaps suit a hairpin or lynch pin, while a permanent installation suits a cotter.

Assortment Kit Sizing

Assortment kits trade quantity per size for breadth of size and style. A 150-piece kit across 15 sizes gives you a wide range to cover different pieces of equipment, but only a handful of any one size — which matters if you burn through one clip type. Check the specific size range and the groove diameter before you order, and look for a labeled case with dividers if the kit lives in a toolbox. Kits are best for shops that work on many machines; single-size packs are better if one piece fails repeatedly.

Common Questions

Will a 5/8-inch hitch pin fit my 2-inch receiver?
Usually, yes — a 5/8-inch diameter pin is sized for a 2-inch shank with a 5/8-inch pin hole, which is the standard setup on most Class III and IV receivers. The CURT 21579, the TOPSHINE four-pack and the B&W TS35010 all run that diameter. The thing to check is the usable length: a 3-1/2-inch usable pin needs a receiver tube deep enough to accept it. Measure the hole and the shank before you order.
What is the difference between a cotter pin and a hairpin R-clip?
A cotter pin is a split pin that bends open after passing through the hole, so it holds firmly but needs pliers to remove. A hairpin R-clip has a straight leg that goes through the hole and a curved spring leg that stays outside and grips the shaft — it pulls out by hand. For equipment you swap often, the hairpin wins on convenience. For a permanent install, a cotter pin’s extra security is worth the fuss.
Should I buy stainless steel or zinc-plated hitch pins?
Stainless is the better choice for anything that lives outdoors or in a damp shed, because the rust resistance goes all the way through the metal rather than sitting on the surface as a coating. Zinc-plated steel costs less and handles normal use well, but the plating is a wear layer and can be scratched through at rub points. On a well-kept truck that is cleaned regularly, plated steel is perfectly serviceable.
How do I repair a trailer coupler that will not lock onto the ball?
If the coupler body is sound and only the latch mechanism is worn, a repair kit like the Reese 74797 can rebuild it. That kit is rated for 3,500 lbs GVW and fits 2-inch couplers, so check both figures against your trailer. If the coupler casting is cracked, bent or rusted through, a kit will not save it and the coupler should be replaced. A ball that is out of round can also stop a new latch from clamping, so inspect the ball too.
Is a HitchSafe cover the same thing as a hitch pin?
No — they do different jobs. A hitch pin passes through the receiver and the ball mount shank to hold them together. The HitchSafe HS7010 is a rubber cover over a metal frame that fits onto the HitchSafe flange to keep the lock assembly sealed against road spray and grit. You buy the cover to replace a perished original, not to secure a ball mount. It is a plastic-and-rubber part, not a load-bearing one.
How many cotter pins should I keep as spares?
Enough that a lost clip does not stop you using the trailer. A 150-piece assortment across 15 sizes gives broad coverage for a workshop, but only a few pieces of any one size. If one specific clip on your ball mount or PTO keeps going missing, a single-size pack plus a labeled case is a better stock strategy. Keep a couple of spares in the glove box so a missing clip isn’t a reason to skip a trip.
Will a hairpin R-clip stay in place under vibration?
The R-shaped design is built for exactly that — the straight leg passes through the hole and the curved spring leg grips the pin or shaft from outside. That spring tension is what stops it walking out under normal vibration. That said, the 300-piece R-clip kit tops out at M3×65mm, which is light retaining work. For a highway trailer, use a proper 5/8-inch hitch pin with a clip designed for that load.
Can I use the same hitch pin on a trailer and a tractor?
Only if the diameters match, and they usually don’t. A standard trailer receiver takes a 5/8-inch pin, while the 202-piece kit from Easily lists a 1.25-inch compatible groove diameter and coverssquare PTO pins and lynch pins for farm equipment. Those are different jobs. A light trailer receiver and a tractor three-point linkage use different hardware — buy the pin that matches each machine’s hole size rather than trying to make one pin serve both. The CURT and TOPSHINE pins suit trailer receivers; the PTO kit suits tractor work.
What size cotter pin do I need for a trailer hitch pin?
It depends on the cross-drilled hole in your hitch pin, which varies by pin model. The safest approach is to buy an assortment with a printed size chart so you can match the clip to the hole. The 300-piece R-clip kit lists a compatible groove diameter of 0.16 inches and covers seven metric sizes from M1×16mm to M3×65mm, which gives you options to match. Check the hole diameter and required clip size before use on any kit.
Do I need a locking hitch pin for security?
A standard pin like the CURT 21579 or the TOPSHINE set is hardware, not a lock — it pulls out as easily for a stranger as for you. If theft deterrence matters, you want a keyed locking pin instead, which is a different product. The HitchSafe cover on this list protects a lock assembly from weather, but the cover itself is not a lock. Decide if you need security or just a reliable pin, then buy accordingly.

The Bottom Line

For most people, the tow hitch spares winner is the HitchSafe HS7010 Replacement Cover because it solves the failure most owners actually hit first — a perished rubber cover that lets water sit against the lock body. It is the smallest and cheapest fix on the list, and replacing the cover beats replacing the whole assembly every time.

If your problem is hardware rather than a cover, the smartest single purchase is the TOPSHINE four-pack for a receiver setup or the CURT 21579 if you want one well-finished pin with a 105-degree grip bend. Anyone with a workshop full of mixed equipment should skip straight to the 150-piece stainless kit, which covers clevis, cotter and R-clip jobs in one labeled case. And if your coupler has lost its grip, the Reese 74797 rebuilds a 2-inch Class 2 coupler instead of making you replace the whole unit.

A quiet nudge: the HitchSafe cover holds 4.5+ stars across 700+ owners, many of whom were replacing a cracked original. Check your own cover this season before the weather does the deciding for you.

How we choose

We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.

Sources

Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of November 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.

As an Amazon Associate, Tactical Gear Guy earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.

Scroll to Top