Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
If your rear paddles have snapped or gone loose, you already know the fix is a small set of metal replacements, not a new controller. What matters most is whether the set fits your Elite Series 2 (or the older Elite 1), whether the paddles stay put when your hands are sweating mid-match, and whether the trigger throw still feels right after the swap.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Some sets give you six pieces for a mixed grip, others trade extra paddles for a single color and fit. The quick table shows exactly how each option lines up on material, paddle count, and grip feel, so you can skip straight to the set that matches your hands and your docking routine when you shop the xbox elite series 2 paddles.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Xbox Elite Series 2 Paddles
A rear paddle is a small metal lever that sits under the back of your controller, so your middle and ring fingers can press a face-button action without lifting your thumbs off the sticks. When the original paddles wear out, go loose, or snap, you replace the paddles — not the whole controller. Here is what to check before you pick a set.
Confirm which Elite model you own
The Elite Series 2 and its cheaper Core sibling take the same paddles, and some sets also fit the older Elite 1. A few kits are built for the Series 2 only and will not seat properly on the Elite 1. Check the model number on the back of your controller — 1698 is the Elite 1, 1797 is the Elite Series 2 — and match it to the listing’s stated compatibility before you order.
Decide how many paddles you actually use
Most competitive players run two paddles, but some sets ship four or six pieces in short and long shapes. Short paddles keep your fingers tucked close to the shell, while long paddles give a longer lever for a quicker press. A multi-piece set lets you experiment with a mix without buying again.
Look at the material and the install style
Stainless steel paddles resist the wear that eventually cracks plastic ones. Most of these sets install without opening the controller — you snap them into the existing slots and go. Magnetic sets are the fast-swap option, while fixed sets sit tight once seated.
Check your charging dock
If you charge on the Elite Series 2 dock, remember some aftermarket paddles have to come off before the controller drops into the cradle. A set that is compatible with the official dock saves you the extra step every night.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Paddle Count | Material | Elite Compatibility | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| eXtremeRate Swift Paddles★ Best Overall | Mixed grip and color customizing | 6 in 1 | Stainless steel | Elite 1 & Series 2 | Amazon |
| DUXICEPIN PaddlesBest Value | Fast magnetic swaps | 4 pcs | Stainless steel | Series 2 & Core | Amazon |
| Ceozon Replacement Paddles | Adding D-pads to the kit | 6 pcs | Stainless steel | Series 2 | Amazon |
| TanReginal Paddles | Purple color refresh | 4 pcs | Stainless steel | Series 2 & Core | Amazon |
| VANPARK Accessories Kit | Full thumbstick and paddle set | 4 paddles + extras | Silicone & metal | Series 2 | Amazon |
| SCUF Elite Series 2 Paddles | Competitive ergonomic reach | Set | Stainless steel | Series 2 | Amazon |
| eXtremeRate Rose Gold 6 in 1 | Matching rose gold build | 6 in 1 | Stainless steel | Elite 1 & Series 2 | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. eXtremeRate Swift Paddles Xbox Elite
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 350+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
Three paddle shapes in one stainless steel bag, built to outlast the plastic set it replaces.
What makes this set the top of the pile is choice. You get three paddle designs in a stainless steel build, so you can run a long lever on one side and a short one on the other and feel the difference the same night. The set fits both the older Elite 1 (model 1698) and the Elite Series 2 and Series 2 Core (model 1797). That dual fit is rare here, and it means the set still works if you upgrade the controller later.
The install is the part that wins people over. You do not open the controller — you drop each paddle into the right slot and play. Each piece weighs around 10 g (a fraction of an ounce), so the balance in your hand stays close to stock. Metal construction is the whole point: stainless steel does not crack or round off the way the plastic originals eventually do. As owners put it, they work “precisely the same and even better than the original paddles.” It is also compatible with the official Xbox Elite Series 2 charging dock, so you are not pulling paddles off every night to charge.
Here is the honest catch. A few owners find the fit and value less convincing than the build — the metal is right, but not every unit seats with the same snugness. The other thing to know is that three designs means a little trial and error before you find your mix. Neither is a reason to walk away from a set this well made. If you want one set that fits both Elite generations and lets you tune the lever length, this is the one.
Where It Pulls Ahead
- Three interchangeable paddle designs in one kit for a mixed grip.
- Fits both Elite 1 (1698) and Elite Series 2 / Core (1797).
- Stainless steel build with no controller teardown needed.
- Works with the official Elite Series 2 charging dock.
What To Weigh
- You will spend a session or two finding your ideal paddle mix.
- Fit can vary unit to unit — seat each paddle firmly.
Reach for this if: you own an Elite 1 or Series 2 and want one metal set that adapts to how you grip.
Look twice if: you only ever use two paddles and would rather not sort through three designs.
2. Paddles Xbox Elite 2 Controller
Snap-in magnetic paddles that skip the tools and the teardown entirely.
If you want the simplest possible swap, this four-piece set is the one. Each paddle attaches by magnet — no tools, no opening the shell — and the magnetic hold keeps it planted while you play. The set is built for the Elite Series 2 and Series 2 Core only, so check your model first. Function is what buyers reward most here: for a plain replacement set, the paddles simply work and fit the way they should.
The build is reinforced stainless steel, and the press feel is tuned to sit close to the original — the rebound and click you already know. The four magnetic paddles pop in and out fast, which makes them handy if you like to run two paddles for some games and four for others. Stainless steel means the parts hold up across long sessions instead of wearing smooth.
The trade-off is scope. This is a paddles-only set — no D-pads, no thumbsticks — so if you also need to replace the sticks, you will want a fuller kit. For the one job of fresh back paddles, though, the magnetic install is the difference you feel every time you swap.
The magnet advantage: tool-free snap-in means a broken paddle becomes a ten-second fix, not a project.
Scope to know: four paddles only, so it covers the back buttons and nothing else on the controller.
Your pick if: a Series 2 owner who wants the fastest swap and a genuine replacement feel.
Skip if: you need thumbsticks or D-pads in the same order.
3. Ceozon Replacement Back Paddles Red
Four metal paddles plus two D-pads, for the player refreshing the whole back end.
This red kit reaches past paddles. You get four stainless steel back paddles — two short and two long — alongside two D-pads, one faceted and one standard. That mix lets you reshape both your rear presses and your directional control in a single order. The shorter paddles suit a tucked, close grip, and the long pair gives you a longer lever when you want a quicker reach.
Install follows the same common-sense approach as the rest of the field: seat each piece in the correct hole and go, no tools required. The stainless steel is chosen for wear resistance, so the parts do not soften over time. Buttons are built for smoother finger control over the length of a session.
One firm compatibility note: these metal paddles are not made for the Elite 1 controller, so this is a Series 2 set. It is also a smaller-name option with a lighter review footprint than the leaders, which is why it sits back in the pack rather than up top. For a red-accent build that wants D-pads bundled in, it earns its place.
What is in the bag: four paddles in two lengths plus a faceted and a standard D-pad — a full rear-end refresh.
Model limit: Elite Series 2 only, so leave it if you are still on the Elite 1.
Worth considering if: you are on a Series 2 and want paddles and D-pads in the same red finish.
Best to pass if: you own the Elite 1 — this set will not fit.
4. TanReginal 4 Pcs Elite Series 2 Paddles
Purple metal that trades four plain paddles for a finish nobody else has.
TanReginal’s angle is the look. The purple stainless steel stands out against a standard Elite shell, and it is built to hold its color over long use rather than fade or chip. The set is four magnetic paddles for the Elite Series 2 and Series 2 Core, and each uses the same tool-free magnet install as the DUXICEPIN set above. At 0.317 ounces, these are among the lightest paddles on this list — lighter than the 0.547-ounce SCUF set — so the balance leans toward a near-stock feel.
Ergonomics are part of the pitch too: the shape is cut for long sessions, and the paddles seat securely during play instead of drifting. Stainless steel gives the wear resistance you want from a replacement part. The magnetic hold keeps each paddle locked in until you deliberately pull it out.
The thing to know is that this is a newer listing with a thin review history, so you are taking more of a chance on the fit than with the established names. If a purple-accent build is the goal and you want light metal paddles to match, the color and the weight make the case.
Where it stands out: a genuine purple stainless finish and a 0.317-ounce weight that keeps the controller feeling stock.
Unknown to accept: a short track record, so the seating and longevity are less proven than the leaders.
Go for this if: your controller already has purple touches and you want light metal paddles to complete the set.
Hold off if: you would rather buy from a set with a long, settled track record.
5. VANPARK Accessories Xbox One Elite Series 2
A full rebuild in one box — six sticks, four gold paddles, and two D-pads.
This is the kit you buy when the whole back end of the controller has seen better days. It bundles 6 black metal Mod Swap thumbsticks, 4 gold paddles (two Medium and two Mini), and 2 gold D-pads, plus a silver thumbstick adjustment tool. The paddles and D-pads are metal; the sticks use silicone and metal, and all of it is removable and swappable without reopening the shell. Quality is what lands most here — the pieces feel solid in the hand, and the heads seat like magnets and stay put unless you pull with intent.
The color story is the eye-catcher: black sticks against gold paddles and D-pads gives the controller a completely different look from stock. Textured grips on the sticks add a little feedback under the thumb. There is also a 6-month warranty backing the set, which matters on a kit with this many small parts.
The honest limit is durability in the finer parts. Durability and build quality are mixed, and some wear shows around the rubber over time. Treat the sticks as the wear item and the metal paddles as the solid part, and the value holds up. The scale of the kit is why it ranks high; the rubber is why you plan to swap eventually.
The Big Draw
- Every replacement part in one box, so you rebuild once.
- Metal paddles and D-pads with a black-and-gold look.
- Swaps without reopening the controller; tool included.
- 6-month warranty covers the full set.
Fine Print
- Durability is mixed — rubber on the sticks can wear over time.
- You are paying for all the extras even if you only needed paddles.
Built for you if: several parts of your Series 2 are worn and you want to refresh the lot in one go.
Not the one if: the paddles are the only thing that failed and you want a smaller, metal-only set.
6. SCUF Elite Series 2 Paddles – Xbox
SCUF’s take on the paddle, cut to shorten the reach from finger to lever.
This set is positioned for feel and speed. The paddles are shaped so your fingers reach the lever with less stretch, which shortens the gap between deciding and pressing. Build is stainless steel, chosen to hold up so you can play without worrying the part will give out. These are made for the Elite Series 2, and they measure 0.93 inches on each side — a small, compact piece compared with the bulkier accessory kits in this list.
The tactile feel is the star. The click and rebound sit where your fingers expect them, which is why the paddle design earns so much praise. The set weighs 0.547 ounces, heavier than the 0.317-ounce TanReginal paddles — a little more heft that some players read as a firmer press. For competitive play, that shorter reach and crisp response are the reasons to step up.
The one thing you must accept: these paddles have to come off to charge the controller on the Elite Series 2 dock. Fit also divides opinion — the paddles pair with the controller, but seating and dock clearance are the recurring notes. Neither undoes the feel advantage. If you want the most tactile, best-positioned paddle for ranked play, this is the set that earns the premium.
The reason to step up: a shortened finger-to-paddle reach and a crisp steel press tuned for fast play.
The nightly chore: remove the paddles before docking to charge — there is no way around it.
Pick these if: you play competitively and feel the difference between a good and a great paddle press.
Think twice if: you charge on the dock every night and want a set that stays on.
7. eXtremeRate 6 in 1 Metallic Rose Gold
The rose gold sibling of the Swift set, with two D-pad designs added in.
If the darker Swift set is the sensible choice, this is the show-piece version. The metallic rose gold finish is the draw, and the four stainless steel back paddles split into two short and two long pieces. Two magnetic D-pads come along — one faceted, one standard — so you can swap your directional control as well. Like the Swift, this set fits both the Elite 1 (1698) and the Elite Series 2 / Core (1797), and it installs without opening the controller.
Quality and the look carry this set. The metal is stainless steel, built to work the same as the original parts, and the rose gold finish holds its color. Fitting is secure and the install is quick — seat each piece in the right slot and play. The two D-pad options give you a real choice in feel that a paddles-only set cannot.
The candid caveat sits in the D-pad function. Some players find diagonals register less cleanly on the faceted pad than they would like, so it is worth testing each D-pad before you commit to one. The paddles themselves are solid. For a matching rose gold build that covers paddles and direction keys, this is the finish to reach for.
What sells it: a rose gold stainless finish plus two D-pad designs, in a set that fits both Elite generations.
Test before you settle: the faceted D-pad divides players on how cleanly it hits diagonals.
Matches your build if: you are chasing a rose gold look and want paddles and D-pads to match.
Maybe not if: you rely on tight diagonal inputs and want only the most proven D-pad feel.
Know the Specs
Material: Why Stainless Steel
The original paddles are plastic, and plastic is what cracks or rounds off after months of pressing. Stainless steel replacements resist that wear, so the press stays crisp instead of going mushy. Most of these sets use metal — the ones that mix in silicone are the full kits where the thumbsticks use silicone for grip. If durability is your worry, stainless steel paddles are the fix.
Paddle Count: Four vs Six
A four-piece set gives you the four back paddles the controller was built to hold. A six-in-one kit adds shorter or longer variants and sometimes D-pads, so you can tune the lever length and the directional feel. If you only ever run two paddles, four is plenty. If you like to experiment with grip and reach, the six-in-one kits pay off.
Install Style: Magnetic vs Snap-In
Magnetic paddles pull out and pop back in fast, which makes swapping or replacing a broken one a quick job. Fixed snap-in sets seat once and stay. Neither needs you to take the controller apart, but the magnetic sets are easier if you change your grip often.
Charging Dock Clearance
If you charge on the Elite Series 2 dock, the shape of your paddles matters. Some aftermarket paddles have to be removed before the controller drops into the cradle, while others clear it. Check this before you buy if you dock every night.
Common Questions
Will these paddles fit the Elite Series 2 Core as well as the standard Series 2?
Do any of these paddles fit the original Elite 1 controller?
Do I have to open my controller to install new paddles?
Which paddles work with the Elite Series 2 charging dock?
Are metal paddles heavier than the plastic originals?
What is the difference between a four-piece and a six-in-one paddle set?
How long do stainless steel paddles last compared with the stock ones?
Can I mix short and long paddles on the same controller?
Do these replacement paddles include D-pads and thumbsticks?
The Bottom Line
The strongest all-round set here is the eXtremeRate Swift Paddles. Three paddle shapes in stainless steel, dual fit across both Elite generations, and charging-dock compatibility make it the one to beat. If you want the fastest tool-free swap, the DUXICEPIN magnetic set is the easy pick. And when the feel of the press is the whole point, the SCUF Elite Series 2 Paddles give competitive players the shortest reach and the crispest steel click, provided you do not mind pulling them off to charge.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of November 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Tactical Gear Guy earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.